Oh no, science to get the Trump “gold” treatment


This is not good news. The Trump administration wants to radically change how science is done in this country.

On Tuesday, the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) released a report entitled “Science: A New Golden Age,” in which it lays out how it has viewed science, found it lacking, and believes the Trump administration is in the perfect position to fix things. It’s a bit unexpected coming from an administration that has been proposing crippling funding cuts to research and trying to enable political appointees to terminate grants awarded based on scientific merit.

The report presents itself as the spiritual successor of “Science, the Endless Frontier,” a policy document that laid out the case for government-funded science in the wake of World War II. The New Golden Age (SNGA) says that, while the concepts promoted by the original remain vital, the circumstances have changed such that we need major revisions to how the government is implementing things.

The result is an odd mix. It completely ignores or glosses over many things that the administration is doing to harm scientific progress. In some cases, it identifies issues that have already been discussed as problems within the scientific community. Elsewhere, it’s a mixture of political grievances, ideas without a solid intellectual foundation, and an injection of Silicon Valley’s perspective on innovation (Michael Kratsios, the director of the OSTP, formerly worked with Peter Thiel). As a result, it’s unlikely to have anything like the impact of “Science, the Endless Frontier.”

“Gold standard”? So he wants to buy some cheap crap from Home Depot, spray paint it gold, and call it science?

Jesus, but he made the oval office kitschy and cheap, and now he’s going to give science the same treatment.

Comments

  1. says

    Yes, Bébé, you get the highest prize like no one’s ever seen! I’s a bigly gold painted plaster star glued to your forehead by the magat-in-chief himself! (sarcasimus maximus)

  2. Hemidactylus says

    Here’s Trumpian “science”:
    https://www.cdc.gov/vaccine-safety/about/autism.html

    KEY POINTS
    -The claim “vaccines do not cause autism” is not an evidence-based claim because studies have not ruled out the possibility that infant vaccines cause autism.

    -Studies supporting a link have been ignored by health authorities.

    -HHS has launched a comprehensive assessment of the causes of autism, including investigations on plausible biologic mechanisms and potential causal links.

  3. says

    Can we add Dr. Ozzzz to the list? He’s such a cheerleader for sciencey medical stuff. Unregulated, unapproved peptides anyone!

  4. raven says

    Oh no, science to get the Trump “gold” treatment

    We all know what this means.
    Everything Trump touches, dies!!!

    It isn’t the least bit complicated.

    -The claim “vaccines do not cause autism” is not an evidence-based claim because studies have not ruled out the possibility that infant vaccines cause autism.

    Actually they have and long ago at that.

    This whole what causes autism is so mid 20th century.
    We’ve known for decades what causes autism.
    It is a lot of polygenic medical conditions with a high genetic component interacting with less well understood environmental factors. A few seconds with Google will answer that question.

    Genetics plays a significant role in the development of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). Studies indicate that autism is highly heritable, with estimates suggesting that 70% to 90% of the risk is attributed to genetic factors.

  5. raven says

    The Trump regime has already done a huge amount of damage to US science.
    It would take decades to recover and it probably won’t anyway.

    My friend was a climate scientist in a nationally known department.
    They all got their funding cut a year ago and have been scrambling to try and support their graduate students and postdocs long enough to finish their current projects.

    She is probably going to drop out of science in mid career.
    Her plans for next year are to teach a few classes and that is it. No money = No research.

    This is happening everywhere.
    Another scientist I know who got hit hard works for the EPA.
    So far he is lucky. They haven’ tried to transfer him to Wyoming and hope he quits instead, which they did to some of the people he works with.

    Science isn’t just an after thought. It is the main driver of our economic progress and our civilization.
    By attacking science, the Trump loons are also attacking…the USA.

  6. drdrdrdrdralhazeneuler says

    “By adopting new social and material technologies, we can again accelerate
    the pace of discovery. It falls to us, as it fell to our predecessors, to imagine new
    machines capable of exploring the endless frontier.” – Apparently, he believes that a technology that swallows trillions and yet can’t build up the number of synapses in the brain (and can’t do basic maths) is more cost-effective than mathematicians.

    I now installed a stock market ticker where I can watch the tech bros go down in real time.

    “At its core, our challenge is that scientific research involves private information that funders cannot directly observe.” That’s putting it very bluntly, actually.

    The document appears to be somewhat self-contradictory, as it simultaneously demands that politicians AND researchers should gain more control over grants. There are entire chapters in contradiction with each other.

    I’m getting the point of protecting technology though: I wouldn’t want any more of mine end up in the hands of your country (no offence).

    Well, your president is certain not to read the document (or this comment) anyway…

  7. indianajones says

    Science to be Marigolded and turned from a vibrant living thing into a statue made of gold eh? Seems legit for this president.

  8. birgerjohansson says

    Maybe some of your researchers and students can hibernate over here in Europe until the Trump glaciation is over?
    With a bit of luck, inertia will slow the project down until the midterms. At that point the Vandal tribe will get other things to think about

  9. seversky says

    “As democracy is perfected, the office of president represents, more and more closely, the inner soul of the people. On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart’s desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron.”

    ― H.L. Mencken, On Politics: A Carnival of Buncombe

    The morons are on the march.

  10. Silentbob says

    (@ ^ Morales

    Remember a few days ago you were claiming ableist language was “deprecated” back in the day? Lol.

    From your link the day was certainly not 2013. X-D )

Leave a Reply