Publicly exposing the ICE thugs


One feature of human nature is that if you give anyone unquestioned power over another human being, they will be strongly tempted to abuse it and become sadistic tormentors. This is true of parents, teachers, priests, nuns, boy scout leaders, military officers, you name it. The chances get even worse if the abusers have anonymity since the shame of exposure is removed, giving them an even greater sense freedom to exercise their vicious fantasies.

This is what we have been seeing with the ICE thugs. These people, many reportedly poorly-trained, poorly vetted, and ignorant, the kind of people who could not get proper jobs in regular life, have suddenly found themselves given powerful weaponry, allowed to wear masks and other disguises, cover themselves with body armor to prevent any harm to themselves, remove any identifying markers, and promised the full backing of the government so that they are free of fear of any repercussions for whatever they do. Is it any surprise that they have turned into roaming bands of goons who feel that they can harass and threaten ordinary people and even injure and kill them for little or no reason?

Since most people cannot fight back with equal levels of force, the public has resorted to the kind of resistance that is available to them, which is develop techniques using social media and even old-fashioned ones like whistles, to quickly gather en masse whenever and wherever ICE appears to document the abuses and to identify them. They also tag and follow their vehicles and create protests wherever they happen to be staying or eating, even preventing them from using gas-station restrooms. This has had the effect of turning much of public opinion against ICE

But perhaps the most potent weapon is the unmasking of ICE agents. One groups of Antifa activists, that used to expose neo-Nazis, has now shifted its focus to identifying the ICE thugs.

Last week a photographer for the Minneapolis Star Tribune filmed a border patrol agent approach a protester, lying prone in the street, and aim a canister of pepper spray at his eyes. The protester was already detained, three other agents pressing his body into the pavement, but the agent can nevertheless be seen spraying the orange chemical irritant, which causes excruciating pain, at point-blank range.

The agent probably thought he would enjoy anonymity for this bit of brutality. The federal police terrorizing Minneapolis remain largely nameless as they dole out horrifying – and in two cases, fatal – violence against anyone opposing Operation Metro Surge. But within two hours of the Star Tribune posting the footage to social media, a group called Pacific Antifascist Research Collective claimed to have identified him.

The collective – which days earlier promised in a post to “identify ICE terrorists until ICE’s campaign of terror is stopped and the armed thugs and their leadership are held accountable” – made flyers of the agent’s face for people to share online, or to print out and tape to telephone poles and buildings across Minneapolis.

“TYLER GRAMLIN”, screamed the text on the flyers in English, Spanish, Hmong, Somali and Tagalog. “SUSPECTED KIDNAPPER/TERRORIST”.

The Pacific Antifascist Research Collective did not publicly share the methods it used to identify Gramlin, but I know its research to be reliable. Its activists follow exacting editorial standards, a tendency born from the desire to be trusted by their communities; any missteps can destroy the credibility of the whole project. 

A longtime antifa activist we’ll call Riley, whose real name they asked be withheld for their protection, is currently involved in researching the identities of ICE and CBP agents. Riley told me these agents often wear masks because they know most Americans “hate” the havoc they are wreaking across the country.

“They want to go about their lives and to enjoy life without being recognized as kidnappers and abusers in their community,” Riley said. “We identify ICE and DHS agents for the same reasons we identify any violent, dangerous people intent on doing harm. They have chosen to prey on the community.” [My emphasis-MS]

“These traveling terrorists need a place to sleep,” Riley said of agents who send immigrants – some of them young children – to these centers, which experts have argued can reasonably be called concentration camps. “They need to get coffee, eat, go to the bathroom, go to the gym, get gas, rent a car like anyone else. Predators should not be able to enjoy anonymity.”

“Antifa is not an organization,” Riley told me. “Antifascism is a natural response to state terror. Antifascist action belongs to the people. Anyone can do it.

Riley, the antifascist, has a message for agents like Gramlin: you might feel invincible now, but the people are turning against you, and the people will win.

This effort has gone global, since the rest of the world is seeing what a hell-hole the US has become.

There is also ICE List, a website run by Dominick Skinner, a 32-year-old Irishman living in the Netherlands, which cobbles together tips about the identities of immigration agents. Skinner told the Irish Times he started the website after seeing the homeland security secretary, Kristi Noem, threaten to arrest Americans who identified ICE agents online. “So I just reshared that and said: ‘That’s cool, I’m not in the US – so send them to me and I’ll do it,’” Skinner told the paper. Skinner claims to have since received the names of ICE agents from bartenders who check their IDs, and from hotel workers where the agents check in as guests.

ProPublica has has also exposed the thugs who murdered Alex Pretti.

The two federal immigration agents who fired on Minneapolis protester Alex Pretti are identified in government records as Border Patrol agent Jesus Ochoa and Customs and Border Protection officer Raymundo Gutierrez.

Ochoa, who goes by Jesse, graduated from the University of Texas-Pan American with a degree in criminal justice, according to his ex-wife, Angelica Ochoa. A longtime resident of the Rio Grande Valley, Ochoa had for years dreamed of working for the Border Patrol and finally landed a job there, she said. By the time the couple split in 2021, he had become a gun enthusiast with about 25 rifles, pistols and shotguns, Angelica Ochoa said.

This is the kind of person attracted to ICE. Someone with a gun fixation who jumps at the chance to freely use them against people.

The Intercept reports that the thugs are also targeting journalists and other witesses who cover them, actively seeking them out and assaulting them.

LESS THAN 40 MINUTES after federal immigration agents shot and killed 37-year-old nurse Alex Pretti on Nicollet Avenue in south Minneapolis, Clayton Kelly was thrown face-first onto the sidewalk, tasting snow and street grime as a federal agent’s knee drove into his back.

The incident, a video of which The Intercept reviewed and corroborated with an independent eyewitness, occurred not long after Kelly and his wife arrived in the area where Pretti was killed. With protesters amassing and agents from Customs and Border Protection as well as Immigration and Customs Enforcement flooding the area, the couple told The Intercept, they just wanted to observe the scene. 

“All of a sudden,” Kelly said, a federal agent “started running toward me, pointing and yelling, ‘That’s him. Get him.’” 

An independent eyewitness who said they did not know Kelly or his wife said they were standing nearby when agents rushed Kelly, tackled him to the ground, and deployed pepper spray, corroborating Kelly’s account of the arrest. After Kelly and Ericson were gone, the witness remained near Nicollet Avenue as federal agents continued clearing the area.
Moments later, the witness said they were grabbed from behind, thrown to the pavement, and sprayed in the face. Medical records from Hennepin County Medical Center reviewed by The Intercept show the witness sustained a fractured shoulder. According to the documentation, the injury will require surgery and months of physical therapy.

[Shauna Kieffer, an attorney with the National Lawyers Guild who is now representing Kelly] described instances in Minneapolis in which attorneys and civilian observers reported being followed by federal vehicles after monitoring immigration enforcement activity, and in some cases later saw federal agents parked outside their homes. One attorney shared video of ICE agents following him and parking outside his house with The Intercept.

In Kieffer’s view, the sheer number of people taken into custody while observing or documenting federal activity has made Minneapolis stand out.

Adam Conover says that these protest actions that we are witnessing in Minnesota, with the people fighting back in increasingly large numbers, are working. ICE CBP, DHS and Kristi Noem are lashing out because they know they are losing the battle for public opinion.

Comments

  1. birgerjohansson says

    Consequences?
    Yes, bring on consequences.
    This is a welcome change from the attitude of Democratic leaders.
    [Warning, angry rant coming]
    .
    Every time one of them becomes president they put “bipartisanship” over everything instead of letting DOJ go after those who misused their authority under the previous administration (there are some low level scapegoats like in the Iran-Contras affair or the Abu Ghraib scandal but never any top brass).
    .
    After Trump # 1 Biden did not bother to go after the immigration officers who abused people the last weeks of the Trump administration. They operated in safe knowledge that the Useless Party never cleans up after Republicans and it makes me so furious I could puke.
    .
    The only way to fight back efficiently is to disconnect the struggle from the heritage Democrat leaders, with some exceptions (Newsom for instance).

    When ordinary people risk themselves protesting in the streets all do-noting politicians should be ruthlessly primaried.
    As you compare USA with the rest of the world it is obvious the Democrats are a center-right organisation and its leaders are living in a separate world than the people who suffer under corporate exploitation and the repressed minorities.
    .
    Fighting the MAGA takeover and its corporate sponsors requires the kind of struggles we saw in Czechoslovakia and Poland during the Cold War, and in pre-war Ukraine and -quite recently- South Korea.
    (Sri Lanka is another case but our flawed media has not covered the struggle against the old elite in that country)

  2. raven says

    The two federal immigration agents who fired on Minneapolis protester Alex Pretti are identified in government records as Border Patrol agent Jesus Ochoa and Customs and Border Protection officer Raymundo Gutierrez.

    I had an argument shortly after the murder of Alex Pretti, that soon enough, his CBP murderers would be identified, on a different forum.

    I said they would, other commenters claimed they would never be identified.

    It took 8 days.
    Murder is a state charge with no statute of limitations. These two guys should be arrested and tried in the state of Minnesota. It probably won’t happen soon, but it should happen someday.

  3. Ridana says

    Excellent rant. If you’re in the mood for more, here normally mild-mannered Technology Connections talks about solar, and then goes nuclear (stolen from comments :)). It’s long, but very worth it. If you just want the powerful call to arms, that’s the last half hour after the credits. But the hour covering solar is also a trove of talking points to use on any fossil fuel fans you haven’t cut off yet, so watch that too when you have time.

  4. file thirteen says

    Reading this is a welcome reminder that there are many fantastic human beings in the US among the dregs and not everyone is sitting on their hands. Props to you all. Breaking free from the corporate-controlled two-party system straitjacket will require superhuman effort, but if a way can be found, you’ll find it.

  5. birgerjohansson says

    # 2
    Defeating fascists is now a task for the grassroots, not the professional politicians but the approval ratings of the traditional polls give an insight in how the tide is turning.
    .
    ‘Let’s Talk Elections’:
    “Donald Trump’s Approval Rating in EVERY SINGLE STATE (UPDATED)”
    .https://youtube.com/watch?v=ckur9Un-ZPw
    A few red islands in the hardest hardcore GOP states, that is all.

  6. garnetstar says

    raven @2, I so agree, I want to see MN state murder charges filed against the two agents, even if MN doesn’t really have enough evidence to try them. Of course they won’t be tried or anything (yet), but MN could issue extradition orders to any state that they go to. Or go there and arrest them themselves and bring them to MN for arraignment. And, ruin their private lives, as in, any other job they try to get the MN murder charges will pop up, they could never set foot in MN again, etc.

    I am very in favor of the names and faces of all ICE gestapo agents. even those who haven’t been filmed beating or killing anyone, being posted online, social media, etc. Get their accounts on social media mobbed, show their families and friends what crimes they’re doing and that they’re part of this criminal organization, make sure that any and all future potential employers see their names and faces and crimes in any internet search. That sure worked with the Charlottesville terrorists.

  7. garnetstar says

    There is perhaps another sign that the protests are working: the district in Texas that just voted in the democrat candidate for state senate, over the republican, by 13 points. This district voted for Trump in 2024 by +17 points. The district is heavily Hispanic.

    Analysis of the vote appears to show that it wasn’t low republican turnout, but rather, all the independents from 2024, and some of the republicans. voted for the democratic candidate.

    Before 1994, California’s state legislature used to regularly go back and forth between democrat and republican control. Then, in 1994, the republicans passed a proposition that “cracked down on illegal immigrants” (meaning, it was extremely racist to Hispanics.) That was the end: democratic supermajorities in both CA state houses ever since, supported by nearly all the Hispanic vote. No house in the CA legislature has been in republican control since then.

    So, perhaps the protests are not just working, but will have a lasting effect.

  8. birgerjohansson says

    Going on a tangent, ICE is the embodiment of an oligarchy defense and enforcement system that has many other layers.
    .
    The impunity of the wealthy for just about anything is just another side of the coin.
    I will add two links about Jon Stewart and Seth Meyers commenting on the list.

    .
    Seth Meyers : “Musk’s Emails to Epstein Revealed; Trump Sues IRS for $10 Billion, Rakes In UAE Money.”
    .https://youtube.com/watch?v=SDuxH6m4ld0
    .
    Jon Stewart: DOJ Protects Trump From Epstein Accountability as MAGA Attacks “Sanctuary Cities”
    .https://youtube.com/watch?v=cwXIq81eE24

  9. beholder says

    @5 birger

    Defeating fascists is now a task for the grassroots

    Oh Birger, my sweet summer child. Demobilizing, defusing, and dismembering the groups who are trying to defeat the fascists will now be the task for the active Trump collaborators: the Democratic party.

    Democrats only change their tune when they are afraid of their voters. These early psychic readings for the midterms will only make establishment Dems more complacent, and reinforces their desire to prevent any change within the party.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *