As is often the case, commenters pick up on some aspect of a blog post that was not central to it and an interesting discussion develops around it.
In my post about poor people living on the edge who sincerely believe that Trump is going to act in their interests and not take any action that might harm them, some picked up on an item in the news report that mentioned that they owned a pickup truck or an SUV, and this was taken as a sign that they were willing to expend what little resources they had to purchase what others might consider a frivolous item they did not need. (Commenter flex entered the discussion with a very thoughtful post that I recommend reading.)
There are some things that are definitely true of life in the US. In most places, some kind of motorized vehicle is essential for people to get to work or fulfill other daily life chores. For many people living on the edge of ruin, what drives their vehicle choice is price. Sometimes an old truck may be all that they can afford. Their purchases are also often driven by the affordability of the monthly payment, not even the actual cost of the vehicle, and so can be persuaded to buy something because of its low introductory payment. Not all buyers are financially savvy and being financially savvy sometimes requires being financially solvent and stable. My choice of a compact sedan (Honda Accord) was made on considerations of its reputation for having low maintenance costs and being trouble free and after having it for 11 years, that has turned out to be true. I could definitely have bought a much cheaper car but could afford to weigh long-term factors over up-front cost. Not everyone has that luxury.
[Read more…]
