Does China know something we don’t?


I kinda sorta envy Chinese science policy.

The Chinese government is ramping up its support for science, announcing plans to boost two key budgets at the country’s biggest political meeting called the Two Sessions.

China has proposed to increase its overall research and development (R&D) expenditure by at least 7% per year over the next five years, which translates to billions of extra dollars each year. This typically covers government and private-industry spending on basic research, applied research and experimental development.

China’s R&D expenditure has skyrocketed over the past 20 years. Last year, it exceeded 3.9 trillion yuan (US$567 billion). For the past five years, it has has increased by at least 8% a year.

They had me at “support for science.” I don’t have an unqualified envy — the USA has been gutting science in this country, which I’d like to see stop — but there’s more to improving science than throwing money at it. China is going to direct money by dictating how it should be spent, and I’d rather see science supported by informed, peer-directed investment.

Unfortunately, the US approach is to slash the science budget and put it under the control of an asylum full of demented lunatics who know nothing about science. We’ve chosen the very worst science policy possible!

Comments

  1. Snarki, child of Loki says

    Oh, I’m sure there’s worse science policies.
    It just takes the Trump admin a while to come up with them, and they’ve been distracted by fascisting.

  2. birgerjohansson says

    If China was not such an awful repressive system (with at least one million prisoners in concentration camps in East Turkestan [Xinjiang in the language of the Han occupiers]) it would be something we could learn from.

    But there are no guard rails. When the fat predecessor had a brain fart in the 1950s 37 million people starved to death.
    ….. ….. ….. …..
    “has increased by at least 8% a year.”
    If the western nations are to keep up, they will have to emulate the “Sputnic scare” from 1957- 1969 with massive investments in education and science.

    But that will require first utterly destroying the far right populists in the various nations.

Leave a Reply