The New Boss, Same As The Old Boss.


A YouTube video from North Dakota’s new Gov. Doug Burgum. More of the same about Standing Rock.

A YouTube video from North Dakota’s new Gov. Doug Burgum. More of the same about Standing Rock.

Damn. Think about what was possible: A governor who is framing his entire administration on innovation just dismissed the most disruptive force in his state’s recent history. That is what Standing Rock is about. Instead of saying, “What can we learn from this? What can we do together?” The new governor relied on the screen saver that was there before; the idea that powerful forces will roll over the tribe and build the Dakota Access Pipeline without interference. Thank you.

Burgum also scratched away at an old story: The Obama administration created this problem.

But his larger message is that the state of North Dakota and its corporate partners are more powerful than any tribal government. Instead of a pause, a moment to engage in a government-to-government dialogue, the new governor emphatically says the pipeline will get built soon. No. Matter. What.

“Make no mistake, this infrastructure is good for our economy,” the governor said in his YouTube video. “And it’s the safest way to transport North Dakota products. Failure to finish it would send a chilling signal to those in any industry who wish invest in our state and play by the rules.”

[…]

The new governor could have reset the law enforcement battle lines too. Nope. “As a result of the Obama administration’s refusal to uphold the rule of law on federally owned land, both our citizens and local and state law enforcement have been put in harm’s way,” he said. “These actions are putting daily demands on the scarce resources of our state and local government.”

Those daily demands are because the state of North Dakota made it so. Pick a word: defuse, de-escalate, negotiate. There were so many better alternatives, ones that were dismissed in favor of sending in the cavalry. I have interviewed many government officials over the years that successfully reduced tension instead of using the police powers of a state. In every test the state failed in this regard and the new governor is following the same path.

I had hopes that Gov. Burgum would see the potential of the Standing Rock story as one that could make North Dakota a beacon. Think about this: This moment in history has brought indigenous people together in a way that’s unprecedented. And the world is paying attention to that. What an amazing opportunity, something that could stir the imagination of investors, entrepreneurs, and governments. Potential partners in a state that found a solution by working with tribes to solve an intractable problem.

The former governor blamed social media for this global perception. But that misses the point that the Standing Rock Tribe owns the story. And that won’t change because the new governor posts a video on his account. The problem is not social media. It’s the message that the State of North Dakota will use the rule of law, the police power of a state, to roll over a tribal nation. It’s a message of brute force instead of inspiration.

Same old tired shit. Same old tired white privilege. Nothing ever changes. Mark Trahant’s full column at ICTMN.

Comments

  1. says

    Burgum is a republican microsoft billionaire. His idea of standing on the right side of history isn’t the same as ours.

    nDakota was almost solidly in favour of Trump. The majority of people here live rural, this is one of the places so talked up during the election and after, and it’s a fine example of the fucking cognitive dissonance of white people -- they want to complain about jobs, this, that, and the other, and who do they elect? A fucking billionaire. Yeah, he’s gonna care.

  2. rq says

    And it’s the safest way to transport North Dakota products. Failure to finish it would send a chilling signal to those in any industry who wish invest in our state and play by the rules.

    I would expect that this is exactly the kind of industry you’d want out of the state (if you were any kind of progressive, forward-thinking governor, that is). I’m sure that would leave lots of space and resources for research or industry in other forms of more sustainable energy. Or, you know, how about those local investments, eh?

    It’s a message of brute force instead of inspiration.

    Because there haven’t been enough colonial genocides already.

  3. rietpluim says

    A chilling effect? To any industry who wish invest… and play by the rules? What about the people who are facing the actual consequences? And what fucking rules does he think of?

    What an ass.

  4. says

    Failure to finish it would send a chilling signal to those in any industry who wish invest in our state and play by the rules

    If you want a real “chilling effect” spray them with a water cannon in sub-freezing weather.

  5. Ice Swimmer says

    Poisoned water and ground will be oh so great for the economy (agriculture) after the oil is depleted or becomes worthless.

Leave a Reply